Patty Schlafer flew in late Thursday from Wisconsin, and her sister, Kathy Coughlin, flew up from Atlanta the same night, for a trip of a lifetime that had been a year in the works.
Along with Mrs. Coughlin’s daughter, Beth Coughlin-Leonard, 32, who lives in Nashville, the women were meeting in New York City to celebrate Ms. Schlafer’s 60th birthday. They had hatched the plan last spring, and kicked around the idea of coming in February until Mrs. Coughlin — who last visited the city for the World’s Fair in 1965 — protested that it would be far too cold.
Pushing the weekend to mid-March didn’t seem like a big deal. They had a fantastic Broadway weekend lined up: “Wicked” on Friday, “Dear Evan Hansen” on Saturday, and on Sunday, for their big finale, “Hadestown.”
Then, as the sisters’ cab made its way from La Guardia Airport to their midtown hotel, the bad news arrived via their phones.
And thus did Ms. Schlafer, Mrs. Coughlin and Mrs. Coughlin-Leonard find themselves among the untold trail of tourists on dream trips to America’s cultural capital with tickets to canceled shows, winnowed options and little in the way of backup plans.
“We talked about it the day before, and we kept saying: ‘Well, Broadway is open. To not go because we’re afraid is crazy,’” said Ms. Schlafer, as she, her sister and her niece strolled midday Friday through an eerily uncrowded Times Square.
Like so many others, they quickly hatched an impromptu Plan B.
The Empire State Building was out — Mrs. Coughlin-Leonard is not big on heights — and so was the subway, because of viral concerns. So, in lieu of shows and museums, they would check out Central Park, the New York Public Library (which closed on Saturday) and maybe Grand Central Terminal, too.
Mrs. Leonard-Coughlin was on the hunt for a bagel or a pastry and a cute cafe. And her mother, Mrs. Coughlin, 65, a supporter of President Trump, had convinced the other two to let her visit the Fox News building, or at least to walk by.
“We told her she only gets 10 minutes of Fox News per hour,” Ms. Schlafer, a self-described “crazy liberal,” said. “We put her on a limit.”
Ms. Schlafer had only been “a little concerned” about the virus. And while her niece had worn a mask on her flight — she is a geriatric nurse practitioner and did not want to transmit anything to the older adults she works with — she had been unaware of the shutdown until her mother called from the cab.
“Beth was already in town shopping, oblivious,” Mrs. Coughlin, 65, said.
“Hello Zara!” Mrs. Coughlin-Leonard sang.
Some other tourists were similarly sanguine about upended plans.
Bryonna Graham, 24, a sales consultant for the Atlanta Hawks basketball team (whose season has been suspended), and her sister Jasmine Graham, 29, a therapist, arrived Thursday from Atlanta and had tickets to “Wicked.” But with Broadway off the table, they concentrated on what was open.
There was the Museum of Sex on Fifth Avenue, though there weren’t a lot of people when they went and they didn’t really want to touch anything. The shops in SoHo and at Chelsea Market were also still fueling customers.
The sisters even managed to take the subway without touching any surface or handrails. After they got back to their room, they sprayed themselves, their clothes and shopping bags down with a can of Lysol they had talked a hotel worker into giving them.
Julie Butler, 52, a school bus driver from Boston who was in town with family and friends for a relative’s 50th birthday, said being in a panic-stricken city had its perks. There was no waiting at restaurants and no lines to stand in.
Sure they were disappointed — they’d had tickets for “Hadestown” and “Jagged Little Pill,” and the television shows “The View,” and “The Late Show with Stephen Colbert,” which both went on without studio audiences. But they could still take a bus tour and could still visit St. Patrick’s Cathedral and the Statue of Liberty. And play board games.
They also had been assiduously handwashing between various jaunts.
“We don’t feel that our threat is heightened by coming here,” said Ms. Butler. “We’re in this together. We need to protect each other.”
Yet for some who came from farther afield, the disappointment was tough to take.
The five members of the Fields family arrived from England Thursday night to find no “Moulin Rouge! The Musical” on Broadway. No ice hockey at Madison Square Garden. No visit to the 9/11 Memorial and Museum. No St. Patrick’s Day Parade.
Maggie Fox, 55, had been planning the trip for her husband and three grown daughters since last summer, and told them about it at Christmas as a surprise.
“We don’t know what to do now because everything’s closed,” Mrs. Fox said. “You walk around and sightsee, but then we can’t go in anywhere and do anything. And then once you’re done then what is there to do?”
And, like many tourists, they had spent hour after frustrating hour trying to contact their airlines and book earlier planes home. Because along with having little to do, there is also the fear of getting marooned.
The Schlafer-Coughlin family had at least been successful on that front. They were scheduled to fly out Saturday morning.
“I mean, who knows,” Mrs. Coughlin-Leonard said on Friday. “Are they going to shut down the airport? I don’t want to be stuck here for two weeks.”
“As lovely as your city is,” Ms. Schlafer said.